Responses to School Buses and Motorists

Responses to First Draft


Andrew Gregory <ny_nma_scc@msn.com> (Thu Jan 1 07:48:10 1998)

Information of Interest: NY NMA Activist

Pull Over When Possible:Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Agree
Overall:Agree

Comments:

My wife & I have a six month old daughter, who of course isn't going to be
riding a school bus anytime soon. As a parent, I would be concerned about
the safety of the bus and the ride. I see nothing in your proposals that
would comprimise our child's safety. In fact, your first two points would
be an added safety benefit.

James M. Mullins, Jr. <jmullins@xwv.net> (Thu Jan 1 23:22:44 1998)

Information of Interest: high school student (president of my class)

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Agree
Overall:Strongly Agree

Comments:

Right on!  I also strongly agree that we need to make school bus trips as
safe as possible. but we also need to make sure that other motorists are
inconvenienced as little as possible, if at all.  Where I live, they're
very bad about holding up traffic unnecessarily.  On the issue of limiting
the use of the red flashers, I've been told that it is against the law in
West Virginia for a school bus to stop on a public road and let anyone on
or off (including high schoolers) without using them.  The best example is
the bridge crossing the river to the neighborhood where I live.  They hold
up two lanes of traffic going in their direction, the traffic coming off
the bridge, and traffic turining off the highway from the other side when
letting kids off at a bride with an elevated sidewalk away from where cars
drive.

Spike Roberson <SpikeRoberson@compuserve.com> (Fri Jan 2 12:49:46 1998)

Information of Interest: Michigan NMA Activist

Pull Over When Possible:Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Agree
Overall:Strongly Agree

Comments:

Regardless of the heat you may have taken on this politically-incorrect
topic, the fact is that the improper routing of school buses, the selection
of bus stops and the over-use of flashers to stop traffic create much of
the hazard for which motorists are routinely blamed.  Here in Ann Arbor, it
is common to see school buses stopping every few hundred feet on the
busiest streets in town and backing traffic up for blocks.  To do business
this way and then complain about the inevitable traffic hazards that result
when frustrated motorists try to pass is simply stupid.  Bus routes should
be planned to create minimal obstruction to traffic and to let students off
in the safest locations.  Most of the time, that means the bus should pull
onto a side-street before turning on the flashers and opening the door.  It
wouldn't hurt to employ bus drivers that were more than dimly aware of the
traffic around them, either.  And Kevin -- get a spell-checker!

parker thomas <mi@motorists.com> (Fri Jan 2 20:42:18 1998)

Information of Interest: mi scc

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Disagree
Overall:Agree

Comments:

Kevin,

In Mi buses do slow traffic and I think we could get support for buses to
pull over when
possible.  In my area most bus drivers do this on there own.  Getting them
not to use
the flashers whenever a kid is getting on the bus or leaving is not too
likely.  It would be too controversial an issue.  The first kid that got
hit, even if
it had nothing to do woth the flashers, by a car when the flashers were off
would
create a media field day.

Parker 

John David Galt <jdg@rahul.net> (Wed Jan 7 12:17:42 1998)

Information of Interest:

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Agree
Overall:Strongly Agree

Comments:

This is but one example of a political system controlled by parents
run amuck.  We need to get through their heads that it is the duty of
parents to keep their kids out of unsafe places; it is NOT the duty
of everyone else to "child-proof" the outside world!  YOU created the
brats, YOU keep them out of my hair, or you shouldn't be allowed to
have them.

Terri Clauss <cen23366@centuryinter.net> (Sat Jan 10 06:27:31 1998)

Information of Interest: school bus driver

Pull Over When Possible:Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Disagree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Agree
Overall:Neutral

Comments:

All drivers should be considerate of all other vechiles on the road
If this means giving up 2 extra minutes of your time to allow a school 
bus pick up / drop off a student of any age. THEN WHY NOT DO SO>>>
Whats the big hurry ? These children are the future. Lets give them a
brake . It's like taking a minute to give a child a HUG...
Lets all be SAFE drivers ! Remember SAFTY FIRST...

Ray Irvine <rirvine@isle.net> (Sat Jan 10 16:43:58 1998)

Information of Interest: parent

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Agree
Overall:Strongly Agree

Comments:

Another consideration: If cars are required to stop whenever a school
bus loads or unloads then the children will become conditioned into
believing that cars will always stop for them, even when the school bus
isn't around.  This will further encourage reckless behavior and in
the long run will probably result in the death or injury of more
children than will be saved by laws requiring cars to stop for school
busses.

Parker Daniels <parkerd@aig.net> (Sat Jan 17 09:52:19 1998)

Information of Interest: this paper

Pull Over When Possible:Neutral
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Disagree
Overall:Neutral

Comments:

You really should have someone read your work for grammer and spelling. I'm
not being
mean or negative -- its just that you will get your message across too many
more 
people if they don't think you are illiterate. You may have written this in
a hurry 
or any number of other circumstances may have caused the many errors in
your "paper"
but it makes you look "not quite all together."

todd cramer <hcramer@gulfsurf.infi.net> (Mon Jan 26 18:31:42 1998)

Information of Interest: student

Pull Over When Possible:Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Disagree
Overall:Disagree

Comments:

As a rider for several years, I have to point out that the system in
Pensacola sets up bus routes so that side streets are used more often than
main roads, simply to make it safer for kids getting off.  I've also seen
kids almost get killed when people who have to get their McDonalds right
away speed around the bus.  I know its a problem, but I don't think it's
necessarily a good idea to limit flasher use.  Kids are stupid, and an
extra minute out of a driver's day won't kill them.  

Anonymous (Tue Jan 27 10:43:46 1998)

Information of Interest: College student

Pull Over When Possible:Neutral
Pull Onto Side Streets:Disagree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Disagree
Overall:Strongly Disagree

Comments:

You say there is only .0001% chance that a child will be killed in
the process of getting on or off a school bus.  I did not have the 
time to look over the additional web pages where you got this information,
but maybe you should include some of the following information:  During
these accidents, what were the situations involving the children that
resulted
in thier deaths?  And how many of them (not saying that they were totally
fault) were due to improper bus signals or the impatience of the the
traffic
around the bus?    

Also, you may want to revise your web page.  I'm not an english major 
and I'm not trying to question your intelligence, but you have many 
grammatical errors in your paper.  In my point of view, this makes your
research and suggestions less effective and other people who view it may 
feel the same.  

Anonymous (Wed Jan 28 15:05:34 1998)

Information of Interest: etc

Pull Over When Possible:Disagree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Disagree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Disagree
Overall:Disagree

Comments:

I generally disagree with this school bus argument. As much as I hate being
perpetually stuck behind a school bus on my cities streets.. there is
a good reason for everything school buses do when picking up and dropping
off children. 

Pull Over When Possible///
Pull Onto Side Streets --- school buses would take forever to deliver
kids to their destination if bus drivers were forced to pull over for 
everyone. Kids would get to their destinations at a unpredictably different
time each day. Bus drivers' schedules would not be kept. Bus drivers
deliver for many different schools each day.(ex. Elementary, Middle, and
High School's)

Use Flashers Only When Necessary - Kids are unpredictable and bus driver's 
can not predict what a kid is going to do when he or she gets off the
bus...
and neither can the automobile drivers on opposing of the street.

How about this argument... I think parents should pick up their own darn
kids.
or What's wrong with home schooling?  Public schools are not very effective
anyway.

Jon Miconi <miconi@hotmail.com> (Mon Feb 2 06:44:50 1998)

Information of Interest: motorist

Pull Over When Possible:Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Neutral
Overall:Agree

Comments:

I agree with the statement that said that buses should pull onto side
streets.  Not only is traffic less dense there, the speed limits are lower.
 If I had a child I would rather he/she get on/off a school bus in a area
where the speed limit is 25 instead of 50.  Cars have less of a chance of
hitting them at that speed, and if they do, there is less chance of it
being a fatality.  Also, if the bus was in a neighborhood, it is probably
closer to the children's house.  And, in a neighborhood, if there is a "bad
person" around, he/she would have more of a chance being seen by the people
that would be home.  When people are at work, they are there to work, not
to watch and see if there is anybody that they don't know trying to pick up
a kid.  One thing you didn't state, that could fit into the pull over when
possible section.  If there was a parking lot on the right side of the
road, the driver could pull into it.  Then, he/she wouldn't have to make a
left hand turn to get into traffic.

Jon Miconi <miconi@hotmail.com> (Mon Feb 2 06:44:56 1998)

Information of Interest: motorist

Pull Over When Possible:Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Neutral
Overall:Agree

Comments:

I agree with the statement that said that buses should pull onto side
streets.  Not only is traffic less dense there, the speed limits are lower.
 If I had a child I would rather he/she get on/off a school bus in a area
where the speed limit is 25 instead of 50.  Cars have less of a chance of
hitting them at that speed, and if they do, there is less chance of it
being a fatality.  Also, if the bus was in a neighborhood, it is probably
closer to the children's house.  And, in a neighborhood, if there is a "bad
person" around, he/she would have more of a chance being seen by the people
that would be home.  When people are at work, they are there to work, not
to watch and see if there is anybody that they don't know trying to pick up
a kid.  One thing you didn't state, that could fit into the pull over when
possible section.  If there was a parking lot on the right side of the
road, the driver could pull into it.  Then, he/she wouldn't have to make a
left hand turn to get into traffic.

Shirley Gitler <gitler@ptdprolog.net> (Sun Feb 8 15:03:50 1998)

Information of Interest: School Bus Driver

Pull Over When Possible:Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Disagree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Disagree
Overall:Disagree

Comments:



Bob Caito <rjcaito@www.swbell.com> (Sun Feb 15 15:48:13 1998)

Information of Interest: driver-to-be (I am almost 16)

Pull Over When Possible:Neutral
Pull Onto Side Streets:Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Agree
Overall:Agree

Comments:



Tamara Knox <tamkins@juno.com> (Thu Feb 26 14:41:37 1998)

Information of Interest: citizen

Pull Over When Possible:Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Neutral
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Neutral
Overall:Neutral

Comments:



Anonymous (Sat Feb 28 09:08:17 1998)

Information of Interest: adult

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Disagree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Disagree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Disagree
Overall:Strongly Disagree

Comments:

There are too many states that do not have strong enough regulations for
the protection of our children (rural and city.  City, roads that children
have to cross without the benefit of a responsible crossing guard.  Rural,
I personnaly have seen to many "hurried" motorist, with no reguard or
respect for a passenger vehicle let alone a vehicle that has 30 children as
passengers.  When laws are relaxed too much then end up being ignored
altogether.  Have you ever seen a child struck by a 3,000 lbs. vehicle that
couldn't stop because it needed to save it's gas or it thought an 8 yr old
child had enough maturity to know not to cross the roa? That child should
know that the vehicle is being driven by someone with the maturity level of
this same 8 yr old and outweighs them by 2960 lbs.

Sabrina <sabrina_thompson@bigfoot.com> (Sat Mar 7 18:42:20 1998)

Information of Interest: Student CNA,Driving adult :-)

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Agree
Overall:Agree

Comments:

I think school bus drivers endanger students more than not, when they
refuse to use common sense and coutisy on the roads. Especially on
highways, were the visability may be limited. By holding up traffic, early
before work, it causes driver stress and iritability. Making drivers more
likely to pass, and or ignore the flashers. In turn, putting more helpless
children at risk.

Anonymous (Sun Mar 8 20:15:57 1998)

Information of Interest: Student

Pull Over When Possible:Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Neutral
Overall:Agree

Comments:

As a student who rides the bus home from school, I would have to agree with
the points you made.  However, in most cases, the time that the motorists
spend waiting for the bus is not that great - at least not from my
perspective; perhaps in your location in may be a worse situation.  Also,
although I basically agree with you and do not feel that your ideas
compromise children's safety, I do feel that drivers should be able to be
patient enough to wait a minute or two. I do not believe that school buses,
on a large scale, create traffic problems large enough to merit required
changes.

Anonymous (Thu Mar 12 15:19:16 1998)

Information of Interest: About to obtain BZ licence, but I have been employed in the industry for 3 years.

Pull Over When Possible:Neutral
Pull Onto Side Streets:Neutral
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Disagree
Overall:Disagree

Comments:

You do have some valid points, however, please remember that
children's safety is of the utmost importance and that the
red signal flashers are governed by law to mean "full stop"
until they are deactivated.  Perhaps those drivers who don't
like the fact that they always have to stop for the school bus
drivers should either....
a)  put themselves in the bus driver's seat and imagine what
it must be like to have so many vehicles constantly trying
to dodge around them
b)  contact the applicable school boards and discuss the 
situation with them since in most provinces and states,
individual school bus companies do not devise the routes.  It
is infact the school boards.
c)  choose alternative routes to travel during peak loading
and off-loading times.

I don't take offense to your report and infact I found it
interesting.  Have you ever considered doing a report on 
the logistics of imposing a law that requires mandatory
seat belts for larger commercial passenger vehicles?

Thanks for taking the time to read over my comments.  I'm
not an expert by any means, but hope to be someday :)

Mike Webster
2nd Year Business Admin. Representative
Canadore College Student Council
Canadore College of Applied Arts and Technology
North Bay, Ontario, CANADA

Robert Saraceno, Jr. <saraceno@ccs.neu.edu> (Sun Mar 15 22:05:16 1998)

Information of Interest: Driver

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Agree
Overall:Strongly Agree

Comments:



David Phillips <davidp@touro.edu> (Wed Mar 18 09:59:15 1998)

Information of Interest: Got a ticket for passing a school bus.

Pull Over When Possible:Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Neutral
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Agree
Overall:Agree

Comments:



Anonymous (Wed Mar 25 23:19:55 1998)

Information of Interest:

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Agree
Overall:Strongly Agree

Comments:

Get rid of these annoying school buses completely!! They should be placed
in
a lane of their own!!!!

Anonymous (Wed Mar 25 23:25:36 1998)

Information of Interest: Sports car driver

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Agree
Overall:Strongly Agree

Comments:

I hate the damn things. While busses can't drive very fast due to their
stability, they can accelerate much faster than they usually do. There's no
reason for bus drivers to not get on the gas when the light turns green!
They should drive at the speed limit, but not take forever to get to it.

Anonymous (Mon Mar 30 16:01:36 1998)

Information of Interest: motorist

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Agree
Overall:Strongly Agree

Comments:

It's bad enough that i have to pay for the school buses, but to have 
them blocking traffic from early in the morning to late at night is
really too much! Here, they provide transportation for kids bigger
in size than i am! I call the buses 'queens of the road' and i'd most 
likely get hung from the highest tree limb by parents if i even hinted
at my annoyance towards towards this very expensive system.   
Glad to hear that there are others that share my concern and are
trying to do something about it. This country has a lot of 'sacred
cows' that touch off high emotions in place of reason,and this is one
one of them.

Thanks for your efforts.

 

 

Anonymous (Sat Apr 4 17:58:20 1998)

Information of Interest: parent

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Disagree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Disagree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Disagree
Overall:Strongly Disagree

Comments:

School bus drivers have enough to worry about without having to 
pull off the road to let children off.If the motering public is in 
that big of a hurry they need to get a life, slow down and live a little.
remember you were a school kid at one time,people had to stop for your bus.
If the buses had to pull off the road they would have to find a safe place
to turn around without 
backing over one of the kids they just let off.Have you ever seen 5 or 6
kids get off and go in one 
direction? They go every which way.What about the kids that has to cross
the street the bus just turned off of 
would they be safe crossing a street without that bus sitting there with
flashing lights on?
BEFORE TRYING TO PASS NEW LAWS MAKING A SCHOOL BUS LEAVE THE ROAD TO LET
OFF OUR CHILDREN. LET US THE DRIVERS LEARN TO SLOW DOWN
WATCH OUT FOR THE BUSES & CHILDREN THERE NOT ONLY MY KIDS BUT YOURS. THINK
ABOUT IT???? 
                                            PS.
                                               I live in the country where
speed limits are 55 mph.
                                                Not the 35 mph. city street
limit
 

Anonymous (Fri Apr 10 18:59:07 1998)

Information of Interest: parent

Pull Over When Possible:Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Neutral
Overall:Agree

Comments:

I think you are on the right track.  One difficulty (and I suspect the
reason the system is now so inflexible) is the lack of maturity and
good judgement in some of the drivers.

Dawn <Dawnd3@yahoo.com> (Sun Apr 12 17:21:22 1998)

Information of Interest: motorist

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Agree
Overall:Strongly Agree

Comments:

I feel that they have the lights flashing when there aren't even children
getting off the bus

Laine Herman <LTS1680@aol.com> (Wed Apr 15 01:05:02 1998)

Information of Interest: school bus driver

Pull Over When Possible:Disagree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Disagree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Disagree
Overall:Disagree

Comments:

Although your viewpoint is well taken, you come off sounding like a
frustrated motorist who has been delayed once too often by a big yellow
school bus!  Try wearing the shoes of a school bus driver!
After you've completed the intensive training including classroom (36
hours) and behind the wheel (24 hours), I believe you may have a different
perspective about frequent stops, turning down cross streets and use of
warning lights.  I'm just completing the above training and now have a much
greater appreciation of all the responsibilities and risks associated with
transporting the "world's most precious cargo!"
I would be happy to correspond further if you're interested.  (I have
almost 20 years of transportation experience-both as a bus company owner /
trainer / consultant.)  

Melissa Algeo <malgeo@bitstream.com> (Fri Apr 24 17:36:28 1998)

Information of Interest: former child :-)

Pull Over When Possible:Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Neutral
Overall:Agree

Comments:

I think it's generally a bad idea to teach children that the whole
world will stop for them, to treat children like unthinking beings
(incapable of checking for traffic), and otherwise to "protect" them
from reality.

Have you seen kids riding bikes lately?  With the helmets and all the
padding, they're practically wearing body armor.  It's crazy.  I was
hurt in a bike accident as a child, and I healed and went biking again.

And of course fireworks are verboten.  Independence Day fireworks
used to be one of the joys of childhood, but modern kids can only
watch passively from a distance as fireworks are set off by strangers.
Most of us adults celebrated with fireworks as children, but now
it's "too dangerous" for modern kids.

It's just not a good idea to teach children to regard normal
activities (like riding a bike, or like setting off fireworks, or like
going to and from school) as a gauntlet of harrowing danger requiring
extensive preparation and control by an authority. The tiny, tiny
number of deaths resulting from normal childhood activities are
certainly tragic for the people involved, but they don't justify the
insane lengths to which we've gone in the name of protecting the
children.

When I was a child, they told us "Safety first."  These days, if
they're honest, they must be saying something like "Total safety at
any cost, even if it means complete immobility and a stifled soul."

Well, that's my rant for the day.  I think a school bus should be
treated pretty much like any other bus.

Anonymous (Sun May 3 12:39:11 1998)

Information of Interest: student

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Disagree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Disagree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Disagree
Overall:Strongly Disagree

Comments:

I think we need MORE warnings to let people know that a school bus is
stopping not enough drivers stop when the bus is letting children off. Now
if you had children on that bus would you want to let all the other cars
just go around giving them a chance to hit the child ?

crystal simpson <simpsonc@westelcom.com> (Sun May 31 19:27:40 1998)

Information of Interest: school bus driver

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Neutral
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Disagree
Overall:Neutral

Comments:

As a school bus driver I feel we need to think of the childern and getting
them to and from school in a safe manner with out holding up traffic. There
are times when we can move over to the side of the road and there are times
when it is not safe to do so. We all have to think of the childern not how
we can't that extra 2 mins. If that was my child on the side of the road
and a drunk teenager comes to fast and runs over him,the teenager has his
life still but, there is a chance my son don't.

Glenn Koontz <gkoontz@ucsinet.com> (Tue Jun 2 17:15:33 1998)

Information of Interest: School bus driver

Pull Over When Possible:Neutral
Pull Onto Side Streets:Disagree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Agree
Overall:Neutral

Comments:

There are some of your comments that I don't agree with at all.

Roger Deschner <rogerd@uic.edu> (Fri Jun 19 03:53:06 1998)

Information of Interest: Motorist

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Agree
Overall:Agree

Comments:

I was neutral on this issue until today. I was delayed 15 minutes by
a school bus which was unloading a couple of handicapped students in
wheelchairs, one at a time, using the wheelchair lift machine
which the bus was equipped with. The red flashers were on the whole 
time, as required by Illinois law, and this being Chicago, it turned
into major-league gridlock.

Finally, I made an (illegal!) U-turn to backtrack and take another
route to my destination, figuring the U-turn ticket would be less
costly than the Passing A School Bus ticket.

These kids could not possibly have darted out into traffic. They
were incapable of it! This is why flasher use should be required only
when necessary. Any logical person would see that unloading a
wheelchair-bound kid is just one of several possible circumstances
that does not require traffic to stop. Especially since it is such a
time-consuming procedure that it creates a delay of such a length
that if a railroad left a train across a crossing that long, the
railroad would be dragged into court and fined!

Katie Sholander <trans443@pld.com> (Tue Jun 23 08:30:33 1998)

Information of Interest: Transportation Supervisor/Parent

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Disagree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Disagree
Overall:Disagree

Comments:

     The theory of your idea has merit,  however when taking the concept
and applying it to real situations it is unrealistic. 
     As a person who deals with students and parents in school bus routing
situations on a daily basis I know you have made some assumptions that are
not true in real life. 
1. Most children are delivered to a home without adult supervision so there
is no adult to monitor the students when they are waiting to board  or
exiting the bus. 
2. A large number of motorists will do almost anything (including illegal
manuvers such as passing on the right or running the stop arm) to avoid
being behind a school bus in traffic. 
3. Engineers rarely design streets in housing areas to accomodate school
buses. Cul-de-sacs were never meant to handle any large vehicle without the
vehicle backing. That traffic manuver is very unsafe expecially around
children. 
4. School bus drivers do attempt to allow traffic to pass when there is
space and visibility to do so. To just "pull over" so traffic can pass is
an invitation to disaster for the students on the bus and oncoming traffic.
5. Since liabilities dictate how we in the U.S.A. do business today, how do
you answer the questions that come to mind? What guidelines do you
establish regarding when to use the loading lights and stop arm?  Whose
child is less important so you don't use those safety features? What about
the freak unexpected accident that no one saw coming ... could the use of
those safety features  made a difference and saved a life?
     How safe is too safe? When it comes to our children and essentially
our future can we be "too" safe? As long as even one (1) child is injured
or killed around a school bus than there is still work to be done to make
the environment in and around the school bus safer.
     

Dave & Mary Thomas <davec80@juno.com> (Fri Jun 26 02:11:23 1998)

Information of Interest: Bus Drivers

Pull Over When Possible:Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Disagree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Agree
Overall:Disagree

Comments:

I really get tired of everybody bad mouthing bus drivers. We have one
of the most chalenging jobs around.  If you don't agree, try putting 60
kids (that don't get along with one another) in your back seat, and go out
in traffic with construction and irate drivers & parents
who want kids transported safely, but when it does not inconvience them.
Let something go wrong and we are the first ones to hear about it. I think
its about time we the motorists start taking some responsibilty for our own
actions and quit look for someone to blame (which is what we are good at)  
  
   

Anonymous (Fri Jul 10 21:58:43 1998)

Information of Interest:

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Disagree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Disagree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Disagree
Overall:Neutral

Comments:

As a parent and also the wife of a bus driver I can say that the buses need
the few minutes to safely load and unload the children.  Everyone today is
in such a big rush.  On the highway I go the speed limit or with the flow
of traffic and yet there is ALWAYS someone who wants to go faster and to
that end will pass on the right or left shoulder if there isn't any other
way.  Most of the buses have a set time that they are at each bus stop
unless they are picking up in - possibly a shopping center parking lot as
is the case here for one stop.  They too must stick to the schedule to get
the children to school on time.  The children, especially the youngest ones
are tired on the way home and may take a bit longer to unload, but it
doesn't count for more than one minute longer in actual unloading time. 
Now lets address the person following the bus.  We live approximately 4
miles away from town on a very busy rural highway.  The bus is at each stop
the very same time every morning so people that just can't have the
patience could leave 5 minutes before or later.  Let's address those in a
rush.  Are they the same ones that read the morning paper and drink a cup
of coffee, or put on their makeup while driving down the road.  You don't
suppose these people always in a hurry are just too lazy to get up either
on time or just 15 minutes earlier to take care of their "needs".  My lord
people, whats the rush to get to a job you probably don't like anyway. 
Just because people get together to complain doesn't make them right, just
loud and collective.  Isn't life going by you fast enough - you don't have
time to enjoy life now.  Isn't there anything more important that you can
think of that needs your time and attention - say people charging you too
much for everything you buy, people on welfare that are fully capable of
working.  Insurance fraud, office theft, corruption in the government, the
year 2000 on your computer, but the bus taking a bit too long for the
safety of children - sorry thing!

Jason Learned <airboat@icanect.net> (Fri Aug 21 22:38:43 1998)

Information of Interest: student on school bus

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Disagree
Overall:Agree

Comments:

I think it has to do with where they put the bus stops. I often have to
walk a long distance to a stop on a main road, with no median to help me
cross. Many times people have almost hit me. I'm a mature 14 year old, and
think about a hiper little elementary student trying to cross. I live in
Miami, and many of the students on my bus do not live anywhere near the
main road. If stops were changed off the main road in the first place,
closer to the homes, it would be safer for the students, less of a hardship
for them to get home, and most of all, it wouldn't hold up traffic!

Fergus Heng Young <csyoung@ihug.co.nz> (Sat Aug 22 07:19:59 1998)

Information of Interest: student

Pull Over When Possible:Neutral
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Agree
Overall:Agree

Comments:

Down in New Zealand where I live it is compulsory to slow down to below
30km/hr passing a school bus that has let of children.  I really do agree
they should be let off in a side street where it's safer.  I strongly agree
with your second point. 

michael gibson <bully@dixie-net.com> (Thu Aug 27 19:50:14 1998)

Information of Interest: new safety on buses

Pull Over When Possible:Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Agree
Overall:Agree

Comments:



Anonymous (Sat Sep 5 06:07:17 1998)

Information of Interest: parent

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Disagree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Disagree
Overall:Neutral

Comments:

The first view is excellent if at all possible.  But usually it is 
not possible due to road and community design.  The second point is 
great too if children will be safe there and getting there.  Lastly,
the flasher should always be used unless it is a four lane road with 
no children crossing the intersection.  As motorist we all break 
the law, please remember this if you can when driving.  I wonder if 
any of the writers have ever seen a child or any human being get hit 
by a car.  I have personally seen a child get hit on the way to work.  
She was crossing a four lane road without an adult.  She started to 
cross when the light was red on the first half of the road.  But as she 
reached the center the light turned green, her body was thrown upper, 
then under both front and rear wheels she went. This was an inner city
accident with a person in a crosswalk with a light changing and the 
driver on their way to work. The driver did not see the child in the 
cross-walk. It is one of the most unpleasant memories I have.  But
current cutting cost for drivers and buses, time constraint on the
operating of buses, and the population explosion are putting all 
school age children at risk.  And the rage on the roads will never 
lessen.  God please help us all, but mostly the children in danger 
ways.

I am mother with four children, my children have caught a bus for 19 
years on a narrow, through fare street.  Currently, the school is 
not wanting to stop at my house which is the safest stop for my third 
child who is eight year old child.  Her dad was hit by a car as child.
My child has to wait at a downhill intersection.  At this 
intersection cars are coming up a hill and running the stop sign.  
And left turning traffic is only seven or eight feet from hitting my
child on a down hill turn.  But the thing is I am dealing with a
principal who is new, who thinks I should get my community to petition
the city on traffic and road conditions.  I guess I should but is she 
doing her job concerning safety. And then there is the DOT school 
executive who does not like me due to prior conservation within the
last five years on this topic.  Which I won against him.  With this 
new school year this well paid man with an assistant, and with the 
aid of a computer to do his job, put some children at risk while 
catering to others at more frequent stops that are well within 
one-tenth of mile of each other.

Sick to Stomach in North Carolina 
morning pick-up on a level sight in the road.  Which is compared to
the dangerous intersection under one-tenth of a mile from my 
house. So to the drivers behind the buses realize some school official
put children at risk already by the book.  
    

Anonymous (Thu Sep 10 14:21:26 1998)

Information of Interest: 24 year old average joe

Pull Over When Possible:Disagree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Disagree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Disagree
Overall:Disagree

Comments:

That would hamper the bus driver too much, they have enough to worry about
already.  Its just part of life, being behind a bus sux.  Let's stick to
stuff like getting rid of speed limits on highways, and leave this stuff
alone.

Anonymous (Mon Oct 12 13:31:12 1998)

Information of Interest: good topic for Government class.

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Neutral
Overall:Strongly Agree

Comments:

I think this is a great idea and would be very helpful when I am running
late and I have to wait for the slow bus in front of me.

Anonymous (Wed Oct 14 15:39:33 1998)

Information of Interest: car driver

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Agree
Overall:Strongly Agree

Comments:

In Texas it's ridiculous. They are now giving jail time to those that pass
a school bus while loading or unloading with flashers on.
Once I remember a school bus driver parked on the opposite side of the road
with flashers on. I was behind two other vehicles so I waited patiently for
the first couple minutes. No kids left or boarded the bus; in fact it
appears the driver was just chatting with a teacher and had left her
flashers on just for the heck of it.
Then, I finally said enough is enough and passed the other vehicles and the
bus. I was tempted to write down more information about the bus and its
location for possible reporting as this was grossly disrepectful to other
drivers. The bus driver who did this deserves to be fired.

BYRON KILBOURNE <BKILBOUR@MICROAGEMN.COM> (Wed Oct 21 17:28:04 1998)

Information of Interest: DRIVER OF CAR

Pull Over When Possible:Strongly Agree
Pull Onto Side Streets:Strongly Agree
Use Flashers Only When Necessary: Strongly Agree
Overall:Strongly Agree

Comments:

I BELIEVE THAT CHILDRENS LIVES ARE IMPORTANT BUT, I DO NOT 
THINK THAT SCHOOL BUSSES SHOULD HAVE TOTALY UNCONTESTED 
RIGHT OF WAY. IN OTHER WORDS IF THERE IS A PROBLEM THEY
CAN WAIT. IF IT IS NESESARY TO USE THE STOP SIGN THEY SHOULD 
ONLY BE ALLOWED TO USE IT AFTER ALL OTHER TRAFFIC HAS PASSED.
I BELIEVE THAT SCHOOL BUS SIZE IS ALLSO A PROBLEM. THEY ARE
SLOW LOW PERFORMANCE VEHICLES WITH OUT EVEN A SEAT BELT. IF 
THE SCHOOL BUSSES WERE SMALLER THE COULD MORE EASILY MOVE
WITH THE TRAFFIC FLOW AND ALSO PULL OFF THE ROAD! NO OTHER
VEHICLE IS ALLOWED TO JUST STOP ALL TRAFFIC WHEN EVER THEY
WANT AND I THINK THAT SOME DRIVERS GET OFF ON THE POWER TRIP!

THANK YOU FOR LETTING ME EXPRESS MY OPINIONS
IS THERE ANY HOPE THAT ANYTHING CAN BE DONE ABOUT THIS
IN MINNESOTA?

BYRON KILBOURNE

Back to Article

Back Home | Start